Validity and Comparability of Out-of- pocket Health Expenditure from Household Surveys: A review of the literature and current survey instruments
نویسندگان
چکیده
Objective: Measurement errors have been a persistent concern in survey research. In this study we investigate the current evidence on measurement errors in self-reported household expenditure and health expenditure. Methodology: We performed a review of the literature on measurement error in healthcare-related surveys. A Pubmed-search was performed and in addition reference tracking was used. In the second part of the study we examined current survey instruments. We collected 90 household surveys, such as household budget surveys, from the International Household Survey Network. We included surveys that were conducted after 1990, with a focus on low-income countries and studied differences in survey design features. Results: The literature review demonstrated that the probability of misreporting increases when the time between interview and event increases. Also, longer and shorter recall periods have generated different outcomes, although the magnitude of this difference varied across populations. Furthermore, respondents reported higher aggregate household spending when more items were used. Respondents may also lose motivation in long-term diaries. Some studies found a relationship between measurement error and respondent characteristics, although results were inconsistent. The review of current household surveys showed a non-negligible variation in design features such as the recall period, the number of disaggregation items and the wording of questions. Conclusion: From reviewing the existing studies and literature we did not find evidence of the optimal survey design features in collecting data on health spending. However, some practical suggestions emerge from the study in terms of question design, recall period and methods of data collection. The study strongly suggests the need for validation studies in order to improve survey instruments and data quality. In the meantime, standardization could improve the comparability across countries and surveys, yet this may discourage the efforts on further exploring the best survey instruments and compromise within-country, overtime comparison efforts.
منابع مشابه
مطالعه هزینههای کمرشکن و منجر به فقر سلامت در جمعیت شهری تهران
Introduction: Measurement of financial support for health services is determined by household out of pocket expenditure for health which is associated with two approaches: catastrophic and impoverishing health expenditures. Therefore, this study aimed to investigate the catastrophic and impoverishing health expenditure in Tehran urban population. Method: This cross-sectional study was con...
متن کاملDeterminants of Healthcare Utilisation and Out-of-Pocket Payments in the Context of Free Public Primary Healthcare in Zambia
Background Access to appropriate and affordable healthcare is needed to achieve better health outcomes in Africa. However, access to healthcare remains low, especially among the poor. In Zambia, poor access exists despite the policy by the government to remove user fees in all primary healthcare facilities in the public sector. The paper has two main objectives: (i) to examine the factors assoc...
متن کاملHousehold Financial Contribution to the Health System in Shiraz, Iran in 2012
Background One common challenge to social systems is achieving equity in financial contributions and preventing financial loss. Because of the large and unpredictable nature of some costs, achieving this goal in the health system presents important and unique problems. The present study investigated the Household Financial Contributions (HFCs) to the health system. Methods The study investiga...
متن کاملContribution of paramedical services costs in health expenditures of Iranian households: The study period 2011 to 2015
Background & Aims of study: Hospital care and paramedical services has become one of the most important and problematic issues in the field of health and critical concern of health planners and policymakers. In current study, contribution of various paramedical services costs were extracted from the total household health expenditure. Materials and Methods: The current study is a descriptive s...
متن کاملبررسی برابری در تأمین مالی هزینه های سلامت خانوارهای ایرانی
Introduction: Health policy makers have long been concerned with protecting people from the possibility that ill health will lead to catastrophic financial payments and subsequent impoverishment. Yet catastrophic expenditure is not rare. We investigated the extent of catastrophic health expenditure as a first step to developing appropriate policy responses.. Methods: Data from household surveys...
متن کامل